Overland Park Water Heaters
The gas control valve and supply line on a gas water heater (illustrative photo)

Gas & Electric Water Heater Repair in Overland Park, KS

Pilot that won't stay lit, or an electric tank tripping its breaker? See what fails on each fuel, then call or text for repair help in Overland Park.

  • Both fuels, repair and replacement
  • Two gas companies, one answer: your bill
  • Call or text, answered 24/7

Water heater trouble?

Water heater trouble? Tell me what's going on, and I'll get right back to you.

* required

!Please enter your name.
!Please enter a 10-digit phone number.

Answered 24/7. Rather talk? Call or text (913) 794-3707.

Every storage tank water heater runs on one of two fuels. Gas burns at the bottom of the tank; electric uses two heating elements inside it. Each fuel fails in its own way, so the repair starts with knowing which you have. This page covers the parts that wear out on each and who to call in Overland Park; for choosing a fuel or a size, the gas vs electric and sizing guide goes deeper.

How do you tell which one you have?

Three quick checks, none of which need a tool.

  • Look up. A gas heater has a round metal flue on top that runs to the roof or a wall. An electric heater has no flue.
  • Look at the connections. Gas means a black iron or flexible line with a shutoff handle near the base. Electric means a cable into a small box on the side or top.
  • Check the label. The data plate lists the fuel, the capacity in gallons and the build date.

A photo of the label sent on the call settles it fast.

What fails on a gas heater?

Gas heaters have a burner and a safety system, so most faults live there.

  • Thermocouple: the sensor that proves the pilot is lit. A weak one makes the pilot die, typically $125 to $250 to replace.
  • Pilot or igniter: soot or a worn igniter, typically $50 to $175.
  • Gas control valve: the brain of the unit, typically $250 to $450.
  • Flue and combustion air: a blocked flue or a starved closet causes sooting and poor performance.
  • Sediment: the burner heats through a layer of minerals, which causes popping noises and wasted fuel.

These ranges are national averages. Your price comes with the call.

What fails on an electric heater?

Electric heaters have no flame, so faults live in the wiring and elements.

  • Heating elements: there are two, upper and lower. When one burns out, the tank stays warm but runs short, typically $150 to $325 to replace.
  • Thermostats: one for each element, plus a high-limit reset button, typically $125 to $275.
  • Breaker or wiring: a breaker that keeps tripping points to a shorted element or a loose connection.
  • Sediment on the lower element, which shortens its life.
PartTypical range (national)Fuel
Thermocouple$125–$250gas
Pilot light or igniter$50–$175gas
Gas control valve$250–$450gas
Heating element$150–$325electric
Thermostat$125–$275electric

Pilot out or breaker tripping? Tell us which fuel you have and get a price.

(913) 794-3707Talk to a plumber 24/7Text Us

Who supplies the fuel in Overland Park?

The City's utilities page lists three energy companies: Atmos Energy and Kansas Gas Service for natural gas, and Evergy for electricity. It says the listed companies are either permitted or have agreements to serve Overland Park. It does not say which gas company covers which street.

That is why your bill matters. The company named on it is the one to call for a gas leak, a meter question or a service interruption.

  • Kansas Gas Service leak line: 888-482-4950
  • Atmos Energy emergency line: 866-322-8667
  • Evergy customer line: 888-471-5275

If you ever smell gas, leave first, call 911 from a safe distance, then call your gas company.

What happens during an outage?

Storms and outages hit the two fuels differently. An electric heater stops heating the moment power drops, though the tank keeps its stored hot water for a while if you leave the taps alone. A gas heater with a standing pilot keeps heating, while one with an electronic igniter needs power to light. After power returns, an electric unit may trip its breaker, and a gas unit may need relighting. If anything smells wrong, treat it as a gas problem and follow the steps above.

When does a fuel-specific repair stop making sense?

The part matters less than the tank behind it. A thermocouple or an element on a dry, younger tank is an easy repair on either fuel. A gas control valve on an older gas tank, or a second element in a year on an electric one, is the point to price a replacement alongside the fix.

  • Water from the tank body: no part on either fuel fixes that.
  • Thinking of switching fuels: that is a replacement decision, not a repair; the sizing guide covers it.
  • Rebates: neither Evergy's Kansas 2026 chart nor Kansas Gas Service's residential rebate page lists a water heater, so ask the utility directly before counting on one.

Does the water matter for either fuel?

Yes, equally. WaterOne's 2025 report (2024 data) puts hardness at an average of about 8.4 grains per gallon, which is hard. On gas, sediment insulates the tank bottom from the burner. On electric, it buries the lower element. A yearly flush and an anode rod check at least every 3 years serve both. The hard water guide explains why.

What does the City require?

Whichever fuel you choose, the City says a permit is required to add or replace a water heater, and the City uses the 2024 International Plumbing Code. A change of fuel adds gas or electrical work to the scope. The City's fee schedule starts at $30 for projects valued under $5,000 and has no water heater line, so ask the permit office at 913-895-6220.

Contractors need an active Johnson County contractor license to get a City permit. Look any company up on the county's contractor search (opens in a new tab).

Gas or electric, repair or swap? Call or text and hear a price first.

(913) 794-3707Talk to a plumber 24/7Text Us

Questions homeowners ask

What is the easiest way to identify my heater's fuel?

A gas heater has a metal flue pipe rising from the top, a gas line and a control dial near the bottom. An electric one has a thick cable or a conduit and no flue. Still unsure? Say so on the call.

Which gas company serves my Overland Park home?

The City's utility list names both Atmos Energy and Kansas Gas Service as providing service in Overland Park and does not map them by street. Your own gas bill is the reliable answer.

Who supplies electricity to Overland Park homes?

The City's utility page lists Evergy as the electric company. Its listed customer line is 888-471-5275.

Is a gas or electric water heater cheaper to run?

It depends on your rates and how much hot water you use. Compare the cost per unit of energy on your own gas and electric bills, and ask for the heater's energy label before you buy.

Why does my electric water heater trip the breaker?

A shorted heating element is the usual cause. If the breaker trips again after one reset, leave it off and call, since repeated resets can overheat wiring.

Do utilities offer a rebate on a new water heater?

Evergy's Kansas 2026 chart omits water heaters, and Kansas Gas Service shows just a water-conservation kit. Ask your utility before assuming either way.

Last updated:

Text Overland Park Water Heaters

Tell me what's going on with your water heater, and I'll get right back to you.

* required

!Please enter your name.
!Please enter a 10-digit phone number.

Rather talk? Call or text (913) 794-3707.