Overland Park Water Heaters
The gas control valve and supply line on a gas water heater (illustrative photo)

Gas vs. Electric Water Heaters and Sizing in Overland Park

Not sure whether your Overland Park house runs on gas or electric, or what size tank to buy? Read on, then call or text for a price first.

Updated

  • Two gas companies, one electric
  • Tank size by household
  • Price before any work starts

Water heater trouble?

Water heater trouble? Tell me what's going on, and I'll get right back to you.

* required

!Please enter your name.
!Please enter a 10-digit phone number.

Answered 24/7. Rather talk? Call or text (913) 794-3707.

How do I tell whether my water heater is gas or electric?

Check the top and the bottom of the tank. A gas heater has a flue pipe leaving the top, a gas line feeding a control valve low on the tank and a small window or tube for the pilot or igniter.

An electric heater has no flue. You will see a conduit or cable entering the top and one or two square access panels on the side. A heater that looks like neither may be a heat pump model, which is taller and has a fan on top.

Who supplies gas and electricity in Overland Park?

The City does not name a single gas company for the whole city. The City's own utility page names two gas companies, Atmos Energy and Kansas Gas Service, plus Evergy for electric, WaterOne for water and Johnson County Wastewater for sewer.

The City adds that the listed companies are either permitted or have agreements to provide service in Overland Park. It does not say which company serves which street, so your bill decides. Read it, or call City Hall at 913-895-6000 if you cannot tell.

Which is cheaper to run, gas or electric?

Compare the two bills for your own house, because rates change and a rule of thumb goes stale quickly. Gas heaters generally heat water faster, which means they recover quicker after a long shower, while electric heaters are simpler and have no flue.

  • Gas: lower typical running cost where gas is cheap, faster recovery, but a flue, a gas line and a combustion-safety check.
  • Electric: no flue, easy to place, simple to install, but slower recovery and a high draw when elements are on.
  • Heat pump electric: very efficient, with ENERGY STAR models rated at a Uniform Energy Factor (UEF) of 3.3 to 4.1, but taller and needing air space.

UEF is the standard efficiency rating, which replaced the older EF rating in 2017. A higher number means less energy per gallon of hot water.

Not sure which fuel your house is on? Call or text and describe the tank.

(913) 794-3707Talk to a plumber 24/7Text Us

What size water heater do I need?

Size follows the number of people, and Rheem's published guidance is the clearest yardstick. These are tank sizes in gallons.

People in the houseTypical tank size
1 to 230 to 40 gallons
2 to 440 to 50 gallons
4 to 550 to 55 gallons
5 or more75 gallons, or tankless

Think about habits too. A household with a soaking tub, a teenager who takes very long showers or a laundry room that runs all weekend wants to be on the larger side of its range. A bigger tank costs more nationally, and the replacement cost guide shows by how much.

Can I switch fuels?

You can, within limits. Going from electric to gas needs a gas line to the heater and a vent to the outdoors, and going from gas to electric needs a circuit sized for the heater.

  • Electric to gas: only works where gas reaches your street or you already have it for a furnace.
  • Gas to electric: requires panel capacity, and the vent gets capped off.
  • Either way: it is a permitted project, since the City says a permit is required to add or replace a water heater.

Switching adds cost, so staying on the same fuel is usually the cheapest route unless the numbers say otherwise.

What about incentives?

Ask your utility before you buy, because programs change and a utility's chart may not list water heaters at all. Evergy's Kansas residential rebate chart for 2026 does not mention water heaters, and Kansas Gas Service's residential rebate page lists only a free water-conservation kit.

Neither utility's published page promises a water heater rebate, so assume none until a representative confirms one in writing. If Atmos Energy is your gas company, ask it the same question.

Does the local water affect the choice?

Slightly. Hard water scales any type, though the effect on a tank differs from the effect on a tankless unit. WaterOne's 2025 report, covering 2024, lists average hardness at about 8.4 grains per gallon, which is hard.

That calls for a yearly flush on a tank and a yearly descale on a tankless unit, whichever fuel they burn. The hard water guide covers both.

What should I do before I call?

Collect four facts and the conversation shortens:

  • Gas or electric, and the name of your supplier from the latest bill
  • The size and manufacture date printed on the tank label
  • Where the heater sits and how big the space around it is
  • How many people use hot water, and how many bathrooms you have

Ready to size and price a new heater? Call or text any hour.

(913) 794-3707Talk to a plumber 24/7Text Us

Questions homeowners ask

Which gas company serves Overland Park?

The City lists two, Atmos Energy and Kansas Gas Service, and says each is permitted or has an agreement to serve the city. Your own gas bill shows which one supplies your address.

Who supplies electricity in Overland Park?

The City's utility list names Evergy as the electric company. Your bill confirms it for your address.

Is a gas or an electric water heater cheaper to run?

It depends on your local rates and your usage, so compare your own gas and electric bills rather than trusting a general rule. Gas heaters usually recover faster.

What size water heater do I need?

Rheem's guidance is about 30 to 40 gallons for one or two people, 40 to 50 for two to four, 50 to 55 for four or five, and 75 gallons or tankless beyond that.

Can I switch from electric to gas?

Yes, if gas is available at the house. It means a gas line to the heater and a vent to the outside, which adds to the installation cost.

Last updated:

Text Overland Park Water Heaters

Tell me what's going on with your water heater, and I'll get right back to you.

* required

!Please enter your name.
!Please enter a 10-digit phone number.

Rather talk? Call or text (913) 794-3707.